A drawing that says “no visible scratches” leaves the decision dependent on the inspector and viewing setup. Before quoting a polished or coated optic, define which surfaces will be checked, what comparison method applies, and how results will be recorded.
Choose the Comparison Method
If the drawing uses MIL-style scratch-dig, identify the governing document and revision. Scratch severity under that procedure is assessed against reference standards; the scratch designation should not be read as a measured width. If your project specifies measured defects instead, state the measurement method and limits explicitly.
Give Inspectors the Same View
Identify surfaces by drawing label and agree on cleaning, illumination, background, and viewing method. Show zones with different limits on the drawing. Decide whether the evaluation occurs before coating, after coating, or both. Keep independent surface figure and roughness requirements in separate drawing notes.
RFQ Checklist
- Surface labels and inspection zones
- Standard revision and inspection setup
- Finished state and reinspection procedure
If the inspected part is a beamsplitter, document its operating conditions and reflection-to-transmission ratio separately from cosmetic acceptance.
Technical reference: edmundoptics.com.